Skip to main content

Cover Songs and the Law



Cover Songs and the Law (copyright)


There have been plenty of lawsuits and or settlements over someone stealing someone else’s song, whether in whole or in part, intentionally or not. Apparently you just can’t be doing that type of thing. I touched on this a bit in previous blogs and there are many examples that I’m aware of (and many I'm not) plus a few more I picked up while doing research, so perhaps a part two or three?

Without getting too technical when it comes to a person wanting to do a cover song they do not need the permission of the owner(s) or writer(s) as the case may be, of the song. There is a thing called 'Compulsory Licence' in the U.S. and similar laws internationally under the 'Berne Convention' that requires compensation be paid to said owners. So in most countries you just need to credit and pay the people who own the song or the 'publishing' rights. I'll blog about that part another time. Then there is the whole idea of  'sampling' a song and how much of it you can use without having to credit the owners. Today I'm focusing on covers where payment and credit was not given originally.

Sometimes it is just the melody, sometimes lyrics, maybe a bit of both or, in the case of John Fogerty you can sound too much like yourself.😕

First let’s get one thing clear, I’m a pretty big John Fogerty fan (I've seen him play twice) and that love would of course include the stuff with CCR (Creedence Clearwater Revival) which for the most part was John Fogerty, so I’m biased here. The other CCR band members that included Johns older brother Tom (deceased Sept. 6, 1990) were talented but John wrote the lyrics, music, had the best voice (somewhat disputed) and was the best musician (undisputed).
As with any break-up there are two sides to every story and with this one there are at least 5 sides, suffice to say John Fogerty's former boss at Fantasy Records, Saul Zaentz and he had a major falling out. So much so John admittedly was so bitter he stopped playing music for almost 10 years. Some years after the nasty split up of CCR, Fogerty recorded two songs aimed squarely at Zaentz, "Zanz Kant Danz" and "Mr. Greed".
So what does all this have to do with cover songs, well believe it or not this is a very short version of a long story, but it comes down to (amid several other lawsuits) Fogerty being sued by Fantasy Records (Saul Zaentz) over the song “Old Man Down the Road”. Written by John Fogerty (1984)

The claim asserted that the song is a copy of the tune “Run Through the Jungle” not coincidentally written by John Fogerty and recorded by CCR in 1970.

Problem was Fantasy Records owned the rights to the song, “Run Through the Jungle” (along with all of CCR’s other songs), John Fogerty did not. Turns out this was a bit of a landmark case during which I’ve read he played guitar to prove his point that the 'CCR' sound was ‘himself’ so naturally some of his songs would sound similar but the two songs were in fact different. The judge found that an artist cannot plagiarize himself. He eventually won a counter suit in Supreme Court to recoup lawyer fees and was awarded 1.35 million dollars.
Ok let’s keep it happy with another cover!
The Old Man down the Road” by Vaneese Thomas 2014

Here are some other songs that have been disputed as covering in whole or in part the original.

My Sweet Lord” (covered over 100 times) by George Harrison (1970) after the lawsuit writing credit to George Harrison and Ronnie Mack.

He’s So Fine” (covered 15 times) written by Ronnie Mack, recorded by the Chiffons. The lawsuit was upheld that this song was the original. George admitted this song my have been in his head while writing My Sweet Lord and he inadvertently used the melody. I completely believe it was not intentional.

The Beatles “Come Together” written by John Lennon, Paul McCartney. Released in 1969

The owners of the Chuck Berry song  "You Can't Catch Me” alleged (Chuck Berry who wrote) the songs lyrics say, "Here come a flat-top, he was movin' up with me," while the Lennon composition includes the lyric, "Here come ol' flat-top, he come groovin' up slowly." here is Chuck's song;

There was an agreement reached with John Lennon to avoid a lawsuit. Once again a Chuck Berry song comes up, seeing how he influenced a whole generation of songwriters and singers he (or at least the various owners of his songs) could have sued a lot of people!
Just a note about the song writing credits for the Beatles songs, most being written by either John or Paul or sometimes both, but all credits have John Lennon's name first and Paul McCartney's name second.  This was a bit of a sore spot for Paul and I saw an interview where he said he would like them changed to his name first if he wrote the song by himself and John's name first if he wrote it solo. I can understand this way of thinking from Paul and I don't think it's an ego thing so much as it's pointing out who was responsible for writing which song. Truth is we pretty much know who actually wrote which song but it's not represented in the song credits.
Not to drone on but when you see the credits on an actual record they just typically list the names of the people 'credited' with the song and not necessarily who wrote the music and who wrote the lyrics. Also sometimes names were added and or changed to give people the financial benefits coming from the publishing rights and they may not have had anything to do with composing the song in any way at all, not to mention aliases used by songwriters for various reasons. 

Ronald Selle alleged his demo song “Let It End” was copied by the Bee Gee’s in
How Deep is Your Love”.   https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CDsaT9xj4A0
How Deep is YourLove” (covered about 150 times) written by Barry Gibb, Maurice Gibb, Robin Gibb released in 1977. Here is a nice short clip from a talk show. Are these guys amazing or what!



How Deep Is Your Love by Chantal Chamberland (2005)

A prior judgement against the Bee Gee’s was overturned. Thank goodness for that!

Queen & David Bowie “Under Pressure” and Vanilla Ice, "Ice Ice Baby".
The case was settled out of court. Bowie and members of Queen all received compensation and songwriting credit on the track, although still not officially listed on the song credits. Here is the original song written by Freddie Mercury, John Deacon, David Bowie, Brian May, Roger Taylor. Released in 1981. “Under Pressure

Dazed and Confused” just like the name of the song I’m confused over this one. There is a song released by Jake Holmes in 1967. Linked below but I suggest you read the rest before you click, 

Jake Holmes album cover
Jake Holmes opened for the Yardbirds for a few concerts in 1967 and shortly after the Yardbirds began playing the song “Dazed and Confused” themselves. Over time the words got changed but they never recorded it. Fast forward to Jimmy Page with his new band Led Zeppelin. More words got changed and the song became this (linked below) released in 1969.
Official song credits were always; Jimmy Page and Robert Plant. Most everyone knows this song as a Zeppelin tune.

Far as I can tell from my reading about this, Jake asked for official song writing credit and some remuneration around 1970 or 1971, they never paid him a penny and basically ignored him.  He did finally bring a lawsuit in 2010 and they settled out of court in 2011 for an undisclosed sum. The song credits now say “inspired by Jake Holmes”. (Secondhandsongs.com credits writers as Jake Holmes, Jimmy Page, Robert Plant) and a best of Album added Jake's name as well. Not the only time this has come up with Led Zeppelin and that alone could fill a blog or three, perhaps another time.

Click here for a playlist of all the Youtube Videos

Cover song trivia: I think I mentioned the Beatles are the most covered 'performers' (apart from Lennon/McCartney themselves as songwriters) but who is number two? Duke Ellington.


If you like my blog, please consider clicking the ‘Subscribe’ button at the top right hand of the home page. Remember to confirm the subscription when you get the first email. Pass it along to a friend who might enjoy it as well! And many thanks as always for reading my blog!

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

One Hit Wonders (not!)

One Hit Wonders (not!)

Yesterday (Sept. 26) was the 50th Anniversary of Abbey Road, the Beatles last recording session together and the second last album before Let it Be was issued May 8, 1970. And also Happy belated One Hit Wonder Day! (Sept. 25th) so I thought it would make a good blog topic.


The simplest definition I found is from music journalist Wayne Jancik "an act that has won a position on a national, pop, Top 40 record chart just once." This from the 'The Billboard Book of One-Hit Wonders' (1998). So we aren't talking one #1 hit. It's not a term I like as it implies (and some truth to that) these artists have had just a brief moment in the spotlight, perhaps undeservedly so and then fallen off the music map. I know other and deeper definitions are a bit more broad and go beyond the absolute single hit idea. They also consider many artists that have still maintained a quality career and just not reproduced another 'top 40 hit' song and or ma…

Old Country New Country

Old Country/New Country


What exactly I am about to attempt to demonstrate I confess I'm not 100% certain, but what I do know is that there has been a bit of a downward sliding scale regarding the enduring quality of mainstream Country Music songs. Apologies in advance for rambling and ranting at various points. This is not a history of Country Music but my opinion on the current state of things in general with the genre.

It's murky waters that I'm swimming in here as there is an evolution involved in any music genre so direct comparisons are perhaps inappropriate. I am somewhat aware of the influence the so called Country Music "establishment" has had on this evolution. One need only look at examples like Taylor Swift, Shania Twain and Garth Brooks and others who were criticized and in some cases "shunned" for their unconventional approaches who are now celebrated as part of that same 'establishment'. So there is some hypocrisy at play in my op…

Sweet Soul Music

Sweet Soul Music

Arthur Conley co-wrote this song with Otis Redding and it's a tribute to some of the early greats of Soul Music. The song's melody (and words for that matter) borrowed heavily from the Sam Cooke song "Yeah Man" and a subsequent lawsuit brought by A.W. Alexander who managed Cooke's songs after his untimely death added his name to the song credits. The resulting song however was a huge hit for Conley and it reached #2 on Billboard's Hot 100 and R&B Chart in 1967 and #7 in the UK where Soul Music was gaining popularity particularly amongst a subset of British youth. The lyrics reference the co-writer Otis Redding, James Brown and songs by The Miracles, Lou Rawls, Sam & Dave and Wilson Pickett, some of the key figures in early Soul Music. "Sweet Soul Music" covered 30 times, The Jam (1977).

Soul music is a fusion of R&B, Gospel and Jazz. Know generally for it's more upbeat tempo it's fun to listen to and great for d…

Rock artists sing the Blues

Rock artists sing the Blues

I have talked about this frequently throughout my posts but more particularly in the series on the Delta Blues and the History of R&R parts 1-4. Truth be told, most of the greatests 'Rock' artists owe much of their inspiration to the Blues. Rock bands and solo artists have cut many sides early and throughout their careers of blues songs. Thanks to artists like Chuck Berry and Elvis Presley who were obviously very well known and successful, their covers of some of the great blues songs served as a conduit and exposed them to artists and listeners alike. Here are some 'Blues' that inspired Rock artists, a few of these songs are more well known than others.


Confessin' the Blues by The Rolling Stones was recorded  June 11, 1964 and released on a 7" record of five songs on August 14. Written by Walter Brown (vocals) and Jay McShann (piano and bandleader) originally released in June of 1941. Covered about 35 times including Chuck Berr…

25 of the Greatest Cover Songs #76-100

25 of the Greatest Cover Songs #76-100

Ok here is the last of my list, I could go on and as a matter of fact I will, just not with another set of 25 plus "to infinity and beyond!" I have to say it was easy to come up with more songs as this final list started at 43. But it was very difficult to decide which ones would make the final cut, so these last 25 songs became a list with a number of great ones left for another day.




76. "Flip Flop and Fly" is a song by the same collection that brought us the classic "Shake Rattle and Roll" written by Jesse Stone (credited to his pseudonym Charles E. Calhoun) and Lou Willie Turner, sung by Big Joe Turner (1955). The first time I heard this was at a club in my hometown I'll say around 1979 or so, performed by the talented Canadian Blues band Downchild Blues Band, later known as just 'Downchild'. Still the best cover for me although I've heard many fine ones out of some over 70 versions, this is a standa…

25 of the Greatest Cover Songs #51-75

25 of the Greatest Cover Songs #51-75

There has been a very positive response to the first two 'Greatest' posts. So the list continues and the songs become no less in their timeless quality compared to numbers one through fifty. I will post a #76-100 edition in the near future and that will be out of my system. But what if I do lists by genre, just thinking out loud, sorry but I will keep blogging on various topics as long as people continue to click.

51. "I Put a Spell on You" written and originally recorded by Screamin' Jay Hawkins in 1956. There have been many really good covers of this song but Nina Simone (1965) was just the second person to cover this song. I just can't get over how overlooked this artist was in her time, a high class version that turns the song on it's ear to give it an entirely different sound.


52. "Strange Fruit" was a courageous recording by the legendary Billie Holliday from 1939. A song written as a poem by another …

Radiohead

Radiohead



When talking about the band I have to confess I'm out of my depth so I will tread lightly. We should however get right to their beginnings and major influence, that being the 'Talking Heads' and their namesake song "Radio Head". The band had been called 'On a Friday' but their record label requested they change it before signing a contract (with EMI records) in 1991.
Radiohead are one of the most successful and influential Rock bands since their debut album "Pablo Honey' (Jerky Boys) in February of 1993. All their songs are credited to the entire band Colin Greenwood, Jonny Greenwood, Ed O'Brien, Phil Selway and Thom Yorke. And there's the 'sixth member' producer Nigel Godrich who's done all their albums since 1994. Their song "Creep" charted top 40 across the world and it's depressing tone eventually wore the band down to the point they stopped playing it live for a long period of time. The songs melo…

25 of the Greatest Cover Songs #1-25

25 of the Greatest Cover Songs

Nothing quite grabs the attention more than a list of the greatest this or that, so at 85 posts about cover songs I thought it about time to get to it. As I advised with my other 'Greatest' posts we all have our favorites so anytime there is a list, something or someone 'great' gets left off. And the debate ensues, why is this and that at #11 not #4 and vise versa. My list therefore, shall be no different for it is not scientific but subjective and it is biased by my own tastes and exposure to music. Having said that it's hard for me to have missed many of the truly great cover songs of all time, indeed I think I've talked about quite a few:


"Respect" from the writer and original recording Otis Redding and a cover she made her own, the Queen of Soul Aretha Franklin. More about the song and Aretha in these posts. Before I get to some cover's I've not mentioned, here are more songs from my previous issues that are …

Music Myths and other Silly Things

Music Myths and other Silly Things

Who doesn't like a good story? There are many great ones and some not so much about music. I try and put a little story into my blogs and during the course of my research I have run across some that are quite curious. Some of these myths about songs and artists have innocent enough beginnings and been perpetuated or at least not denied by the artists themselves, others come from malcontents and the misinformed.



Here is one that falls in the category of a silly thing; Bob Dylan and the 'Stealers Wheel' song "Stuck in the Middle with You", released in April, 1973.

1. Bob Dylan did not write this nor did he sing this song, nor is this song about Bob Dylan.

2. If you do a search for 'Dylan and Stuck in the Middle" you will get results like the following:
Home » Artists » Bob Dylan » Stuck In The Middle With YouBob Dylan - "Stuck In The Middle With You" lyricsBob Dylan: CD's Sheet Music Tablature, Stuck in the …

25 of the Greatest Cover Songs #26-50

The next 25 of the Greatest Cover Songs #26-50

In part one I listed 25 of the greatest cover songs and to date it's been my most viewed blog post. There are so many more I wanted to add to the list so depending on the response, I'm prepared to follow with 51-75 and 76-100 in the future.

This list in part comes from many of the songs that I have already posted in the past 15 months or so since I started blogging. As for how songs make it on my list there are a few criteria, while I don't dismiss music from more recent years a song has to have stood the test of time for me, hence much of the list are songs of some vintage and just plain old, like the writer. Next, the original song itself must have some character and some degree of popularity. And preferably the artist and or songwriters are of interest as well. I have read other lists of great cover songs from books, articles and google searches and you'll find much similarity, but some of them contain songs I just don…